Hilfe & Kontakt

"Drug War" Policies Need a Stint in Rehab

Von: Dan Clore (clore@columbia-center.org) [Profil]
Datum: 30.04.2010 03:25
Message-ID: <4BDA3182.2030400@columbia-center.org>
Newsgroup: alt.society.anarchy alt.anarchism alt.fan.noam-chomsky alt.activism alt.politics.libertariansoc.rights.human alt.drugs alt.fan.rawilsontalk.politics.drugs talk.politics.libertarian
News & Views for Anarchists & Activists:

"Drug War" Policies Need a Stint in Rehab
By Stephen Leahy

UXBRIDGE, Canada, Apr 29, 2010 (IPS) - The war on drugs is a complete
failure everywhere, according a comprehensive review of 20 years of
scientific literature released at the Harm Reduction 2010 conference in
Liverpool, England that wraps up Thursday.

"The war on drugs does not work, period," said Dr. Julio Montaner,
president of the International AIDS Society.

"We must take an evidence-based approach to dealing with the drug
market, because current strategies are not working and people are paying
for ill-considered policies with their lives," Montaner said in a release.

An examination of all English-language scientific literature dating back
more than 20 years reveals that drug law enforcement dramatically
escalates drug-market violence. Contrary to conventional wisdom, a
startling 82 percent of the studies found the various wars on drugs in
countries and internationally simply increase violence.

Mexico offers a case in point. In 2006, it launched a massive nationwide
counter-narcotics campaign. By 2008, drug violence claimed 6,290 lives
in that year alone - double the number from the 2007. In first eight
weeks of 2009, more than 1,000 people were killed. Since 2006, the total
number killed has surpassed 17,000 people, including scores of judges,
police, and journalists.

"From a scientific perspective, the widespread drug violence in places
like Mexico and the U.S., as well as the gun violence we are
increasingly seeing on city streets in other countries, appears to be
directly linked to drug prohibition," says review co-author Dr. Evan
Wood, a researcher at the Canada's British Columbia Centre for
Excellence in HIV/AIDS and founder of the International Centre for
Science in Drug Policy.

The organisation is an international network of scientists, academics,
and health practitioners committed to improving the health and safety of
communities and individuals affected by illicit drugs.

The review was released in Liverpool at the 21st international
conference on the reduction of drug-related harm. Harm reduction
involves providing access to methadone, needle exchange services, and
counselling for drug users.

The 26-page report, "Effect of Drug Law Enforcement on Drug-Related
Violence: Evidence from a Scientific Review", notes that drug
prohibition has created a massive global illicit drug market, with an
estimated annual value of 320 billion dollars.

Further, several of the studies included in the report suggested that
violence stems from power vacuums created by the removal of key players
from the illicit-drug market by drug law enforcement. As police use
increasingly sophisticated methods to disrupt drug-distribution
networks, levels of drug-related violence may rise.

The research also reveals that governments that rely on a tough-on-crime
approach to attempt to control drug-related harms will only burden
taxpayers and will likely create more drug-market violence within their

"These findings are consistent with historical examples such as the
steep increases in gun-related homicides that emerged under alcohol
prohibition in the United States," the report states.

"Prohibition drives up the value of banned substances astronomically,
creating lucrative markets exploited by local criminals and worldwide
networks of organised crime," said Wood.

While the U.S. currently has 500,000 people in jail on drug offences -
five times as many as 20 years ago - the availability of illegal drugs
and drug use has not changed. In fact, illegal drugs are cheaper and of
better quality, the report observes.

Former presidents of Brazil, Colombia and Mexico have signed a statement
that begins: "Prohibitionist policies based on eradication, interdiction
and criminalisation of consumption simply haven't worked."

Criminalising drugs and as a consequence drug users serves as a barrier
to public health objectives, and has no other purpose other than to
punish, Gerry Stimson, executive director of the International Harm
Reduction Association (IHRA), told IPS. IHRA exists to prevent the
negative social, health, economic and criminal impacts of illicit drugs,
alcohol and tobacco for individuals, communities and society according
to its website

"Law enforcement is the biggest single expenditure on drugs, yet has
rarely been evaluated. This work indicates an urgent need to shift
resources from counter-productive law enforcement to a health-based
public health approach," Stimson said.

Laws criminalising drug use "must be repealed", he said.

Two of three major British political parties during the run-up to
parliamentary elections have gone on the record as wanting an informed
debate on drug decriminalisation. That's an encouraging development,
says Stimson, who hopes that Britain will take the lead on this issue.

Current drug policies are also bad for the farmers in Burma and
Afghanistan who grow opium in order to survive, Tom Kramer of the
Transnational Institute, an academic think tank devoted to social
justice, told the conference on its final day. Opium farmers need their
own harm reduction strategy, said Kramer

"If we accept that people consume drugs, then we need to accept that
people produce drugs and protect the rights of poor producing
communities," he said in a release.

In one final session, the mayor of a community in one of the major
coca-producing regions in Colombia told participants: "The harm provoked
by drug control policies is displacing farmer families, destroying the
forests and does not resolve the fundamental problem of drug availability."

Dan Clore

New book: _Weird Words: A Lovecraftian Lexicon_:
My collected fiction: _The Unspeakable and Others_
Lord Weÿrdgliffe & Necronomicon Page:
News & Views for Anarchists & Activists:

All laws are good, to those who draw a salary for
their enforcement.
-- Clark Ashton Smith

[ Auf dieses Posting antworten ]