nntp2http.com
Posting
Suche
Optionen
Hilfe & Kontakt

Re: Palin Rumor

Von: Dover Beach (moon.blanched@gmail.com) [Profil]
Datum: 03.09.2008 23:13
Message-ID: <Xns9B0E9AF07893moonblanchedgmailcom@130.133.1.4>
Newsgroup: alt.fan.cecil-adams
Boron Elgar <boron_elgar@hotmail.com> wrote in
news:unutb4hvuikluhnha3htqhpid7irjdk0p3@4ax.com:

>
> http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0887/is_n10_v16/ai_19989442&tag
> rel.res1?tag=col1;fa_related_widget
>  It is well established that periconceptional folic acid
> supplementation can reduce a woman's risk of bearing a child with a
> neural tube birth defect. The mechanism of this protective effect has
> not been clearly established, however.
>
> A commentary in The Lancet suggests that folic acid may act through an
> unusual mechanism: selectively promoting the spontaneous abortion of
> defective fetuses. This type of effect, called terathanasia, has been
> hypothesized for other substances and demonstrated in at least one
> animal model.
>

I think our posts are crossing each other at sea.  I have one long post
where I quoted the same article as your first one, and then I had one
where people were arguing with each other about the statistical analysis
of the studies and whether anything useful was shown.

Shirley was asserting that it was well-established that folate causes
the spontaneous abortion of NTD babies.  Barbara and I were shuffling
around in the research and questioning whether it was really
well-established or indeed, established at all.  I haven't pursued it
further in the last hour but I stand by the reading that I did that
suggests that indeed, spontaneous abortion of NTD babies in the presence
of folate is not even somewhat established, let alone well-established.

--
Dover

[ Auf dieses Posting antworten ]

Antworten